Movies

The Black Cauldron

As the 25th animated Disney film, The Black Cauldron is definitely the least known film of Disney’s Bronze Age.  It was also the first Disney movie to use CGI animation (or computer- generated imagery) and the first ever Disney movie to be rated PG.  When the film was released (after a complicated production process), it was not received well by critics as they thought the movie’s tone was too dark and the script was bad; and though the animation voice acting and score received praise, the film also did poorly financially, grossing 21 million but costing 44 million to make.  And to add insult to injury, it was outgrossed by its rival movie The Care Bears Movie.  Despite its reputation, it has a small cult following today.  This movie is definitely the strangest movie I’ve reviewed so far, and I actually had plans to skip this one; but after learning the movie’s history (it almost bankrupted Disney’s animation department), I decided that it played too important a part to skip.  I would love to hear your thoughts on this relatively unknown Disney film!

The Black Cauldron (loosely based on the book series The Chronicles of Prydain) is about a young assistant pig keeper, Taran, who wants to be a warrior.  Soon into the movie, he finds out that the pig he takes care of, Hen-Wen, has the power to see into the future; and Hen-Wen then has a vision that the Horned King is after her so that the King can use her to find the Black Cauldron (so that he can resurrect his army of the dead and destroy Prydain).  What a guy!  Taran’s mentor/boss sends Taran off with Hen-Wen to protect them both but Hen-Wen gets captured anyway due to Taran’s foolishness.  Taran then goes on a quest to find her and to defeat the Horned King once and for all (while meeting some interesting characters along the way).  This is quite the movie and does surprisingly have some nice parts (like how very adorable Hen Wen is!); and on some level, I can appreciate parts of it since it reminds me of the fantasy books that I like to read.  But, it’s hard to know what morals it’s trying to send out to watchers, as this movie is the darkest out of all the Disney movies I’ve reviewed and is extremely flawed in other ways too.  First of all, the Horned King is super dark and could definitely give young kids (or just about anyone) nightmares; second of all, I didn’t like the main character, Taran, at all, as he is very rude to Princess Eilonwy, a girl he “befriends” when captured by The Horned King.  Taran  says that she can’t do anything heroic cause she’s a girl, so I do hope they didn’t end up together because Eilonwy deserved better than that jerk!  He is very rude also to Gurgi a most adorable character that he meets, calling him a coward for being scared of The Horned King.  Speaking of Gurgi, there is a disturbing scene regarding him; when Taran and crew (minus Gurgi) are captured, Gurgi feels that everything is his fault so he jumps into the Black Cauldron and dies.  This scene seems to imply that he took his own life because he felt as if he had no friends.  Overall, I would strongly caution parents of any kid due to the violent scenes in this film, the rudeness of Taran and, most importantly of all, the death of Gurgi.  I really do hate that Gurgi took his own life because he felt so very, very alone.  I wish he knew that life does get better, whether he could see it or not in the moment he was in.  Even when life here is really tough, there is always hope that it will not always be so.

“What does a girl know about swords, anyway?” (Taran)

“’Girl’?  ‘Girl’?  If it wasn’t for this girl, you would still be in the Horned King’s dungeon.” (Princess Eilonwy)

6 Comments

  • Walinda

    Wow! I had never heard of this one. It’s a bummer that the main character is not loveable and exemplary. I loved the history you provided, and agree that that made it worth reviewing. But I can see why it didn’t do better at the box office. Thanks for deciding to review it! Great writing as usual!

    • EvangelineFiles

      Yeah It’s a shame that Taran was not more likable because the movie really did have a lot of potential. Thank you for sharing your thoughts!

  • Loyal Fan

    I do not remember this movie. However I did see Care Bears (out at the same time). It does not sound like a movie that I would like to see. It seems very complicated and Taran was not very nice.
    You did a good job writing the review. You have a lot of details and history about the book. It is amazing that it cost 44 million to produce and grossed so little.
    It is indeed sad when a person feels no hope. Life and circumstances can be so overwhelming at times that we can loose sight of that hope.

    • EvangelineFiles

      I think I might have seen Care Bears when I was younger. I don’t remember it very well though. I don’t blame you for not wanting to see The Black Cauldron, the tone of the movie is definitely not for everyone. Thank you for sharing your thoughts!

  • Tiger

    Wow, this really does sound like a dark film! Thank you for educating us about it (as I wasn’t familiar with it at all). The part you share about Gurgi sounds so very sad; I really do hate that his life ended that way, and I’m very thankful that you decided to write about that part. It seems that you did so in order to encourage others to hang on to hope for as long as they possibly can because better times for them might be just around the corner. As always, I love your perspective (and I think it’s great that you chose, once again, to point out the film’s “girl power”). Looking very forward to your next review, Evangeline!

    • EvangelineFiles

      The part of the film where Gurgi dies really did disturb me. and yes, I did share that part of the movie for the reasons you mention above: to encourage people that life does get better whether we realize it or not. Yes, the films “girl power” was quite something! Thank you for sharing your thoughts! The Great Mouse Detective is coming up next!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *