Books,  Neurodivergence

Speak

Author: Laurie Halse Anderson

Today I’m going to be reviewing a book I really enjoyed, a book that was actually a banned book.  When Speak was published back in 1999, it received positive reviews from critics and was a bestseller; and the book was made into a movie in 2004, starring Kristen Stewart, but it seems like the movie went unnoticed when it came out.  I hadn’t heard of it at all before I read the book.  However, despite the book’s positive reception, it was banned by many schools/libraries across the U.S.  The reason behind the ban was because of the novel’s inclusion of rape, language, and a supposed bias against male students.  I have been wanting to do a review of a banned book for a while and I’m very excited to do so now.

Dedication: To/for my former teacher and now media/technology mentor and dear friend (you know who you are)

Melinda Sordino’s not off to a great start with high school, as she called the cops at an end-of-summer party without telling anyone why and now all of her “friends” have turned off of her.  So, Melinda retreats to her head and stops speaking for the most part; but Melinda is lonely, her grades are going downhill, and she’s very depressed.  She wants to speak up about what really happened to her at that end-of-summer party but she’s afraid someone won’t believe her.  This powerful novel, told in a journal “entry-ish” fashion, it is beautifully written.  While it’s a little slow at first, I enjoyed watching Melinda’s character develop and I loved Mr. Freeman’s character as well.  Also, even though this book deals with a very hard topic (rape), there are actually some funny moments throughout the book.  I could actually relate to Melinda some on a personal level, as I had a hard time in school but loved art class; and I frequently find common ground with fictional characters/historical figures just like Melinda did.  However, this book does deal with the topic of rape/sexual assault, and this part of the book is very hard to read and could be triggering to those who have been through what Melinda went through.  There’s also some language too, and I noticed that in the last part of the book the “R-word” is used once; while this word was not used towards a person, it’s still a very hurtful word used toward people with disabilities and I’m surprised that Anderson put this word in here.  So, I would caution parents due to the rape and the language (and the R word for those who are triggered by that as well), and I would recommend it for teens only.  Another thing I noticed about the book is that one of the reasons it was banned is that people thought it was biased against male students, probably because of the book’s storyline.  However, this was most definitely not the case.  The main message I picked up from this book is that you have to use your voice to speak up when things aren’t fair.  Some people like Melinda are scared to speak up, and sometimes they find their courage and sometimes they don’t.  That’s why we need to speak up whether it’s speaking up about violence against women, mental health awareness, racism, ableism, etc.  I hope that after reading this review you will try to use your voice to speak up about injustice in your own life and in the lives of those around you.

“When people don’t express themselves, they die one piece at a time.”

A quote from Mr. Freeman Melinda’s art teacher

6 Comments

  • Walinda

    I’d never heard of the book or the movie. It’s definitely a heavy topic and one that resonates with me. I’ve decided to read it. I just borrowed the audio version from the library. I’ll let you know what I think when I’m done.

      • Loyal Fan

        I have not read the book or seen the movie. It sounds quite good. I can not imagine going through such a terrible thing and not being able to share it with anyone.
        However often times we go through a lot of unpleasant experiences and bottle them up inside and keep them there. That certainly is not healthy. It definitely affects us.
        Knowing when to speak up and the way in which to express ourselves is something that all of us need to work on. It must be done with love and a desire to improve the situation and increase an awareness of certain problems.

  • Tiger

    Another most excellent job, Evangeline! I had never heard of this book but am very interested now in checking it out. And what a profound quote! I love that (and will probably use it myself at some point). I love, too, the message you took from this book about speaking out for any person or group that you see being hurt in some way. That’s such an important message, especially now. I’m also intrigued about the fact that this was a banned book at some point in recent years. But we just can’t not talk about the most difficult things, like sexual assault, just because they are so difficult; I think that means we need to talk about them even moreso. And your pic is so very lovely-simple and elegant. Thanks, Evangeline, for your messaging!

    • EvangelineFiles

      I’m glad that the post resonated with you! I look forward to hearing your thoughts after you read the book! And I agree with what you said about how we need to talk about difficult topics more than we already do. Thank you for reading!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *